The first meeting with a prospective accountant sets the tone for everything that follows, yet many business owners walk in unprepared, focused only on price. Fees matter, of course, but they tell you almost nothing about how responsive, proactive or genuinely useful an accountant will be once you have signed up. Asking the right questions at this stage can save years of frustration and thousands of pounds in missed opportunities or avoidable mistakes down the line.
Ask Who Will Actually Handle Your Account
It is worth asking directly whether you will have a single, named point of contact or whether your queries will be handled by whoever is available at the time. Many firms present senior partners in the sales meeting and then hand day-to-day work to junior staff afterwards. There is nothing inherently wrong with that model, but you deserve to know upfront rather than discovering it later, when problems arise and you cannot easily reach anyone experienced enough to help.
Ask specifically how senior the person managing your account will be, and whether you retain access to more experienced staff for complex or urgent matters. This is where the distinction between a basic compliance service and something closer to virtual finance director services becomes important, since the latter typically guarantees senior-level attention as a standard feature rather than an occasional upgrade.
Ask How and How Often You Will Hear From Them
Contact frequency and method should never be left as an assumption. Ask whether updates are proactive or purely reactive, whether you can expect quarterly reviews or only annual filings, and what the typical response time is for a routine email or phone call. Get specifics rather than vague reassurances like "we're always available," which usually means very little once the relationship actually begins.
- How often will we have a scheduled review or check-in?
- What is the typical response time for a quick question?
- Will I have a direct phone number or named email contact?
- How do you flag deadlines and changes that affect my business specifically?
Ask About Their Experience With Businesses Like Yours
Every sector has its own quirks, from construction industry scheme rules to hospitality VAT complexities to the particular cash flow rhythms of retail. Ask how many similar businesses the firm currently works with, and request an example of a challenge they helped a comparable client solve. Vague, generic answers here are a red flag; specific, confident examples suggest genuine, relevant, hard-won experience that is genuinely worth paying for.
This question also reveals something about communication style, since accountants who genuinely understand your sector tend to explain things using examples that are immediately relevant to you, rather than generic textbook language that leaves you doing the translation work yourself every time.
Do not be afraid to push for specifics here. Ask how many businesses of a similar size and turnover they currently support, and what proportion of their client base looks broadly like yours. A firm that genuinely understands your world will answer quickly and with concrete detail; one that has to think hard about it is telling you something important before you have even signed anything.
Ask How Fees Work Beyond the Headline Price
A low headline fee can hide additional charges for phone calls, emails, or anything beyond the bare minimum compliance work. Ask explicitly what is included in the quoted price and what triggers an extra charge. Transparent firms will answer this clearly and often put it in writing; evasive answers here are worth taking seriously as a warning sign about how the wider relationship will actually run.
It is also worth asking how fees are reviewed over time and whether increases are flagged in advance or simply appear on the next invoice. Predictability matters as much as the initial number, especially for a small business managing a tight monthly budget with little room for surprises.
A useful follow-up question is to ask for a worked example: what would a typical month or quarter of communication and support actually cost for a business roughly your size, once every likely extra is factored in. Firms confident in their pricing will happily walk through this; firms that avoid the question are worth treating with a degree of healthy caution.
Ask What Happens When Something Goes Wrong
No accountant gets everything right every time, and how a firm handles mistakes tells you far more than how they handle routine work. Ask directly how errors are corrected, who takes responsibility, and whether there is a clear process for raising a complaint or escalating a concern. A confident, honest answer here is far more reassuring than a firm that insists mistakes simply never happen at all.
This question also opens a useful conversation about escalation: if your usual contact cannot resolve something, is there a clear route to someone more senior, or do queries simply sit unanswered? Knowing the answer before you need it is far better than finding out during a genuine crisis moment.
Pay attention too to how the answer is delivered. A firm that treats the question seriously, describing a genuine, documented process, is signalling a level of professionalism that a vague or dismissive answer simply cannot match, regardless of how confident the rest of the meeting felt.
It is also worth asking how quickly a corrected figure or amended filing would typically be turned around once an error is identified. A firm with a fast, well-rehearsed correction process is usually one that has handled this situation many times before, which is itself a reassuring sign of genuine experience rather than something they are awkwardly figuring out for the very first time on your account.
Ask for References or Examples From Similar Clients
A firm confident in its service should be happy to share references or at least detailed, specific examples of how they have supported businesses similar to yours. Genuine enthusiasm and concrete detail here, rather than vague generalities, is often the clearest signal of how the relationship will actually feel once you are a client rather than simply a prospect being pitched to for the first time.
Trust Your Instincts Alongside the Answers
Beyond the specific questions themselves, pay attention to how the meeting feels overall. Did they listen carefully to your business before offering advice, or did they launch into a generic pitch regardless of what you had actually said? Did they ask thoughtful follow-up questions, or move quickly to discussing fees? These softer signals often predict the day-to-day relationship just as reliably as any single question on this list, and they are worth weighing seriously before making a final decision.
The Bottom Line
The first meeting with a prospective accountant is your best opportunity to judge fit before committing, so use it well. Ask about who handles your account, how often you will hear from them, their relevant experience, transparent fee structures and how mistakes are handled. Firms offering structured, senior-level support such as virtual finance director services are usually well prepared for these questions, which itself is a useful signal for London business owners weighing up their options carefully before making a final decision that will genuinely shape their finances, and their peace of mind, for years to come.
Want Direct Access to Senior Financial Advice?
Let's build a relationship you can actually rely on
Fred Michael & Co Ltd offers direct, dedicated access to experienced financial support, including our virtual finance director service.